WITHOUT GIVING THE MOVIE AWAY (Hindi movie reviews...and a little more)
Not sure which movie to watch today? Check out the genre by rating table
Find reviews by or or or

Jaane Tu ya jaane na - Review

4th July 2008 | posted in Hindi Movies, Reviews, meetu |

Looks like youre new here. You may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

Alternate Names: Jaane tu, jane tu, jane tu ya jane na

Rating: Wait for video release (Rating Scale)

Movie Info, Detailed ratings, To each his own, Parental Guidance

good fun

Quick Review

The only word that comes to mind is ‘cute’. No less and unfortunately, no more.

Rating: Wait for video release (Rating Scale)

Jaane tu is sweet, but not saccharine sweet. It’s more the fun, peppy sweet. Yet it does not reach the heights of a lasting entertainer, mainly because of the sudden limp in the story 3/4ths way down the line. It just came across as aimless and rather random after that.

However, the spoof-ish undercurrent running through the movie is completely adorable. The digs on all things “Hindi cinema” are thoroughly enjoyable. And I could almost sense how the writer is having a hearty laugh by having the audience lap up, the mother of all clichéd climaxes, without complaining.

The college campus feel of the movie is going to make the young identify with the characters and their situations. And the slightly less young will enjoy the nostalgia. I liked the way various relationships were built. Be it the mother-son, the father from the portrait-son, the brother-sister, and of course friends and lovers - all these equations came across well but yet had an anti-climatic feel about it.

Genelia and Imran Khan both bring a breath of freshness on the screen. It’s as much their timing as it’s the natural, much needed casualness they afford their characters that make them dear to the audience. I especially liked the insecure, confused, disappointed body language that Genelia presented in the second half. We know for sure that they are here for the long haul, at least for the chirpy, less serious kind of roles.

Anything “Aamir Khan” has to have music that adds to the ambience of the movie and its true with this one too. So, even with a forced in number like “pappu can’t dance” you find yourself swaying to the music. While there isn’t a shred of doubt that “kabhi kabhi aditi” is one of the most romantic numbers to have come out in recent times, “pappu can’t dance” and “nazre milana” have also grown on me with repeated hearings.

To be honest, I just don’t feel right judging a movie while sitting in the corner seat of the third row (from the screen). The camera angles, the colors, the sound - all seem off to me. So, I think it’d be unfair to make any comment on any of these aspects.

So, yeah, I had a smile on throughout the movie but the base story is a little disappointing in terms of originality. I felt a little cheated by the ultimate turn of events somehow didn’t go with the tone of the movie and thus made it land in the “much ado about nothing” category.

Parental Guidance:

  • Violence: Very little. A punch here and a punch there.
  • Sexual content: None.
  • Concept: It is about relationships. So, though its fun, its still something only a teenage might begin to understand.
  • General Look and Feel: It does have a rugged look and feel, which means no saturated colors. But, the songs and the overall feel of the movie is happy.

Click here to read what I scribbled on my notepad while watching this movie (what worked and what didn’t for me). Might contain spoilers!

Click here to see what 29 other reviewers/viewers think. Average rating 3.6 / 5.0: 17 thumbs up, 8 so-so, 4 thumbs down.
If you enjoyed reading this, please help maintain this site with a donation

- Meetu, a part of the audience

Rating: Wait for video release (Rating Scale)

Detailed Ratings (out of 5):

Direction: 3.5 Story: 2.5
Lead Actors: 3.5 Supporting Cast: 3.5
Dialogues: 3.5 Screenplay: 3.5
Music: 3.5 Lyrics: 3.5

Jaane Tu ya jaane na - Details

Director, Story, Lyrics: Abbas Tyrewala
Music Director: A. R. Rahman
Genre: Romance
Official Website: Jaane Tu ya jaane na
Duration: 2:40 hrs (approx.)

30 comments

Articles linking here

  1. Anonymous
  1. 1 On July 5th, 2008, chavanni said:

    chavanni’s review…

    http://chavannichap.blogspot.com/2008/07/blog-post_779.html

  2. 2 On July 5th, 2008, vimal said:

    Nice review. I too felt the same thing. Dont know why all the other reviewers are raving about this movie. According to me, except for the treatment, everything else in the movie was just too normal (and dragging at times too!)

    Btw, where is ur usual nitty gritty section?

  3. 3 On July 5th, 2008, priyanka shukla said:

    yu guys are mad, how silly to think about a story
    must having sexual contact,rubbish,change the sites name keep it without thinking and going to a movie ha,ha.

  4. 4 On July 6th, 2008, Ps said:

    Thanks for sharing this!This was one movie I wanted to go and watch.

  5. 5 On July 7th, 2008, meetu said:

    Hey Vimal, have been busy with one thing or the other, that’s why couldn’t do the nitty-gritty section. Its on my ‘to do’ list for today.

  6. 6 On July 7th, 2008, morph said:

    if i had gone purely by your rating for movies released this year , i would have died of Cinema starvation waiting for “vidoes” to release!..do you work in some racket for Moser Baer..LOL !!

    whats wrong with this movie now? wont one have a good time watching this on big screen ?!! why does it get clubbed with that monstrosity called De Taali ? are you saying this one is only as good as De Taali !..Seriously ?!

  7. 7 On July 7th, 2008, morph said:

    @Ps

    You should !.. go ahead and watch this one .

  8. 8 On July 7th, 2008, meetu said:

    morph, hey!!! have been missing you. Where were you all these days?

    Believe me, I did ask myself if this one was only as good as ‘De Taali’. Well it is, but only a shade. And that shade shows in the detailed ratings.

    The way I thought of it is - both are movies about friends falling in love with each other or otherwise. Both were trying to entertain. Both made me go “awwww” at a couple of places. ‘De Taali’ made me laugh really hard at a few places and ‘Jaane tu…’ made me smile throughout.

    !!! mild spoiler ahead !!!

    What was wrong with the movie? Well, besides the fact that i didn’t like the way things ended up because it was no different from any other ‘boy meets girl’ movie, i didn’t think the individual pieces or bits added up to make a very good ‘whole’ product. It was better than decent, but not great.

  9. 9 On July 7th, 2008, Mayur said:

    “Waiting for Godot” is a famous play where characters wait for Mr. Godot, interestingly he never arrives :)

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waiting_for_Godot

  10. 10 On July 7th, 2008, meetu said:

    Thanks Mayur! Should have wiki’ed it in the first place…

    anyways, but it still makes no sense in the context of the movie…it was a random tribute, i guess.

  11. 11 On July 7th, 2008, morph said:

    hmmm..not a random tribute ..its like the movie’s lead pair who were waiting for “true love” to arrive from some other place but it never did .

    it was much much better than decent and definitely leagues ahead of de taali …

  12. 12 On July 7th, 2008, morph said:

    btw between a movie that makes me “laugh at few places” and a movie that makes me “smile throughout” , i will take the latter any day .

  13. 13 On July 8th, 2008, meetu said:

    hmmm, morph…i enjoy metaphors, even if i don’t get them the first time around, but this one seems a little forced, if your interpretation is correct.

  14. 14 On July 8th, 2008, Subur said:

    Sob! sob! sob!… I was expecting u to atleast say…’Watch for sure - preferably in theatre’ but got disappointed… Sadly its a sad review for a HEP! film…:)

  15. 15 On July 9th, 2008, meetu said:

    Hey, come on Subur, if I were sitting in a premiere with the director, Aamir Khan, the cast (especially Genelia, right?) around me, I’d tend to like the movie a little more than usual. No?

    I assume the excitement in the air is different when you are watching a premiere. I know for sure the excitement is different for a first day first show in comparison to a few days later.

  16. 16 On July 9th, 2008, Nisha said:

    I think its an awesome movie. I have been following your reviews for quite some time and I have noticed that the seriousness about the cinema which seeped in after you had gone for the course in Film appreciation.
    However, I would like to say I know camera angles etc are important. But every movie has its own flavor. I see most movies in the theatre and what I like watching is the energy a movie generates amongst the crowd and how engaging it is.

    Although Aamir might have been a great movie with everything technically correct, it was a little too long for people to stick around and watch intently. Jaane tu.. might not have been technically correct but the crowds went crazy watching it, loving it. Is that totally irrelevant when you review a movie?
    When readers like me come looking for a movie review, what exactly are they looking for? an entertaining and engaging movie or a technically correct movies with a balanced number of longshot, medium shots and closeups?
    Kindly reconsider your rating which tripe like De taali, mindless Thoda pyar thoda magic, dhamaal, dus kahaaniyan.. have also got.
    Thanks

    Nisha

  17. 17 On July 9th, 2008, meetu said:

    Hey Nisha! Welcome back!!

    I really don’t think I let the technical aspects overwhelm my opinion of the movie. For me the movie is more about what the director’s/writer’s most likely intention was - then it may be to pass on a social message or tell a story or entertain. Then, I see if it worked for me and try to dissect why I liked/disliked it. Believe me, this has been natural, not a laboured effort, so much so as to spoil my experience of the movie.

    Case in example, Summer 2007, it must have been one of the worst movies, technically. But, none of that can over-ride the awareness it was trying to create. It worked in sensitizing me to the issues of our farmers.

    Seriously Nisha, I try to keep the reviews about my opinion, because there is no way I can claim that I know the pulse of the “crowd”. I am no mind-reader. I am ‘a part’ of that crowd, so I will know only what that ‘part’ feels about the movie.

  18. 18 On July 10th, 2008, Ridhima said:

    I loved the movie and genelia was a like a fresh air in the middle of all des plastic faces dat r der in bollywood today…and i simply adored Imraan and his voice. I throughly enjoyed the movie and its music.Sign up on Planet Radio City to get all the latest info about ur fav music and singer/composer. Also get lyrics and meet others who like your kinda music. Spread the word about your favourite music.

  19. 19 On July 10th, 2008, iwebie said:

    I think its a cool movie and a muct watch for Youngsters

  20. 20 On July 11th, 2008, Arijit said:

    No doubt this is a pleasing movie.This movie has brought a fresh air in bollywood after few month.

  21. 21 On July 11th, 2008, Nisha said:

    Hey Meetu, good to see that my comments got published.. I was a little apprehensive :)

    Anyways, I am not in habit of giving comments until and unless they become indispensible. I was shocked to see the review for Jab we met and same thing happened for Jaane tu.. Do you see a similarity? Its not as if I am a big fan of feel good movies. Maybe you have to give them some brownie points. Maybe somewhere everything in these movie adds up so that the viewer leaves with a big grin pasted on his face and remembers it for next few weeks.
    Anyways thats just my opinion.
    Would you be covering Osian’s btw if you are delhi based? They show some great movies there.I saw quite a few last year, and great collection I must admit.
    Hope to see you there.

    Nisha

  22. 22 On July 15th, 2008, meetu said:

    Hey Nisha,

    Why would I not publish your comment? Because you did not agree with me? Never…differences of opinion are one of the most enjoyable things!

    I do realize that I am a little harsh on the “romantic” feel good movies. The thing is my rating is based on the feeling I come out with while walking out of the theater (as you agree it should be). Both these movies, left me feeling something was missing. Jaane tu gave me that feeling a lot more than Jab we met.

    I’m not Delhi based and can’t attend Osian. I don’t mind to have you as a guest on wogma if you want to cover the festival. Do let me know what you think.

    Thanks!!

  23. 23 On July 15th, 2008, Nisha said:

    wow.. I am flattered. :)
    Last year I attended most of the movies. (Best being Jaagte Raho on big screen!)
    But then I was on a vacation, I would be really lucky even if I can attend couple of movies this year. That wont be fair to the festival at all..
    Thanks anyways :)
    Nisha

  24. 24 On July 16th, 2008, meetu said:

    Ok, i understand, Nisha. But, any time if you’d like to write your opinion of any movie (except latest Hindi, maybe because I cover them anyway), or a movie related topic, do let me know. Of course, we’ll have to do a trial run, etc, but that will come once you are on board.

  25. 25 On July 16th, 2008, Nisha said:

    Sure!.

  26. 26 On July 19th, 2008, VR said:

    I think the movie is cute, as you said, but at times, it tries just too hard to be cute, and the characters come out as unreal. I might have enjoyed this movie when I was in my teens, but today, I think too many scenes appeared just too sugary for my taste.

  27. 27 On July 19th, 2008, diana said:

    ok i like jenni very much and the heros acting is too good i like kabhi kabhi aditi song very much

  28. 28 On August 3rd, 2008, Deekchhya said:

    Oh great!kabhi kabhi afiti is such an awesome song!this film is a must see & its great

  29. 29 On August 14th, 2008, dilan younis said:

    hi..its great and i like it alot…

And what do you think...

  • Ads

All reviews arranged by genre and rating
Must see - on the big screen Watch for sure - preferably in theatre Wait for video release Watch if you have nothing better to do Switch channels if it’s on cable!
Action Batman - The Dark Knight Don
Get Smart
Quantum of Solace
The Bourne Ultimatum
The Forbidden Kingdom
Kidnap
Race
Risk
The Kingdom
Cash
Dhoom 2
Hijack
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
Shootout At Lokhandwala
Love Story 2050
Mr White Mr Black
Mummy - Tomb of the Dragon Emperor
Speed
Tashan
Adventure The Forbidden Kingdom Drona
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
Animation Ratatouille Jumbo
Krishna
Return of Hanuman
Dashavatar
Roadside Romeo
Based on true life story 21
Parzania
Black Friday
Shootout At Lokhandwala
Biography A Mighty Heart Gandhi my father
Provoked
Comedy Lage Raho Munnabhai Bheja Fry
Cheeni Kum
Ek Chalis Ki Last Local
Get Smart
Honeymoon Travels Pvt. Ltd.
Kabul Express
Ratatouille
Welcome to Sajjanpur
Bachna Ae Haseeno
Bhoothnath
De Taali
Jab We Met
Pyar Ke Side Effects
Salaam-e-Ishq
Bhool Bhulaiyaa
Dostana
EMI
God Tussi Great Ho
Hello
Hulla
I See You
Khosla ka Ghosla
Mumbai Salsa
Namastey London
Naqaab
Om Shanti Om
Oye Lucky Lucky Oye
Saas Bahu Aur Sensex
Sunday
Ugly aur Pagli
Darling
Jhoom Barabar Jhoom
Kya Love Story Hai
Mr White Mr Black
Tashan
Crime Don
Ek Chalis Ki Last Local
Johnny Gaddar
Manorama Six Feet Under
Traffic Signal
Contract
Dus Kahaniyaan
It’s Breaking News
Risk
Righteous Kill
Shootout At Lokhandwala
Ram Gopal Varma ki Aag
Welcome
Dark Comedy Mithya
Must see - on the big screen Watch for sure - preferably in theatre Wait for video release Watch if you have nothing better to do Switch channels if it’s on cable!
Diaspora Khuda Ke Liye
The Namesake
Loins of Punjab Presents Namastey London Marigold
Docu-drama Summer 2007
Drama Batman - The Dark Knight 1971
21
A Mighty Heart
Aamir
Apna Asmaan
CHAKDE! INDIA
Dor
Fashion
Guru
Kabul Express
Khuda Ke Liye
Nanhe Jaisalmer
Parzania
Shaurya
Tahaan
the blue umbrella
The Namesake
Traffic Signal
Umrao Jaan
Bhoothnath
Bow Barracks Forever
Contract
De Taali
Dus Kahaniyaan
Gandhi my father
Hope and a little sugar
Jab We Met
Jannat
Metro
Provoked
Pyar Ke Side Effects
Risk
Sarkar Raj
The Last Lear
thoda pyaar thoda magic
U Me Aur Hum
Water
Woh Lamhe
Bhoot Unkle
Black Friday
Halla Bol
Hello
Jodhaa Akbar
Khosla ka Ghosla
Khoya Khoya Chand
Kismat Konnection
Laaga Chunari Mein Daag
Righteous Kill
Saawariya
Shootout At Lokhandwala
Yuvvraaj
Zindaggi Rocks
Bas Ek Pal
delhiiheights
Dhan Dhana Dhan Goal
Mehbooba
Mission Istanbul
Ram Gopal Varma ki Aag
Shakalaka Boom Boom
Family Tare Zameen Par Apna Asmaan
The Namesake
Baabul
Gandhi my father
Heroes
Hope and a little sugar
Nishabd
Ta Ra Rum Pum
Khosla ka Ghosla
Laaga Chunari Mein Daag
Mere Baap Pehle Aap
Oye Lucky Lucky Oye
Gauri The Unborn
Vivah
Waqt
Fantasy Chain Kulii Ki Main Kulii
Nanhe Jaisalmer
the blue umbrella
Bhoot Unkle
Saawariya
Heist Cash
Dhoom 2
History Jodhaa Akbar
Horror 1920
Bhool Bhulaiyaa
Phoonk
Gauri The Unborn
Must see - on the big screen Watch for sure - preferably in theatre Wait for video release Watch if you have nothing better to do Switch channels if it’s on cable!
Kids Tare Zameen Par Chain Kulii Ki Main Kulii
Nanhe Jaisalmer
Ratatouille
the blue umbrella
Bhoothnath
Jumbo
Krishna
Return of Hanuman
Ta Ra Rum Pum
thoda pyaar thoda magic
Bhoot Unkle
Dashavatar
Drona
Hari Puttar
Melodrama Aaja Nachle Baabul
Ta Ra Rum Pum
Eklavya
Karzzzz
Namastey London
Om Shanti Om
Aap Kaa Suroor
Aryan
Kya Love Story Hai
Marigold
Vivah
Waqt
Murder Mystery Ghajini Sunday Red
Murder Suspense Strangers
Musical Lage Raho Munnabhai Aaja Nachle Heyy Babyy
Jab We Met
Salaam-e-Ishq
Jaan-E-Mann
Om Shanti Om
Saawariya
Yuvvraaj
Zindaggi Rocks
Jhoom Barabar Jhoom
Marigold
Shakalaka Boom Boom
Mythological Return of Hanuman Dashavatar
Mythology Krishna
Noir Dasvidaniya
Ek Chalis Ki Last Local
Manorama Six Feet Under
No Smoking
Bow Barracks Forever
Dhokha
Mithya
Nishabd
Oh My God
Woh Lamhe
Must see - on the big screen Watch for sure - preferably in theatre Wait for video release Watch if you have nothing better to do Switch channels if it’s on cable!
Patriotism Heroes 1920
Philosophy Oh My God
Politics Khuda Ke Liye
Manorama Six Feet Under
Dhokha
Gandhi my father
Sarkar Raj
Halla Bol
Jodhaa Akbar
Relationships Apna Asmaan
Dasvidaniya
Dor
Fashion
Rock On
The Namesake
Dil Kabaddi
Dus Kahaniyaan
Gandhi my father
Jab We Met
Metro
Nishabd
Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi
Sorry Bhai
Dostana
Khosla ka Ghosla
Khoya Khoya Chand
Mere Baap Pehle Aap
Mumbai Salsa
Rama Rama Kya Hai Dramaaa
Waqt
Religion 1920
Romance Cheeni Kum
Guru
Honeymoon Travels Pvt. Ltd.
Traffic Signal
Umrao Jaan
Bachna Ae Haseeno
De Taali
Dhokha
Heyy Babyy
Hope and a little sugar
Jaane Tu ya jaane na
Jab We Met
Jannat
Metro
Nishabd
Pyar Ke Side Effects
Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi
Salaam-e-Ishq
Ta Ra Rum Pum
U Me Aur Hum
Woh Lamhe
Bhool Bhulaiyaa
I See You
Jaan-E-Mann
Jodhaa Akbar
Khoya Khoya Chand
Kismat Konnection
Mere Baap Pehle Aap
Mumbai Salsa
Namastey London
Om Shanti Om
Partner
Saawariya
Sunday
Ugly aur Pagli
Zindaggi Rocks
Aap Kaa Suroor
Aryan
Bas Ek Pal
Bombay to Bangkok
Darling
delhiiheights
Jhoom Barabar Jhoom
Kudiyon Ka Hai Zamana
Kya Love Story Hai
Love Story 2050
Marigold
Mehbooba
Shakalaka Boom Boom
Vivah
Welcome
Satire Loins of Punjab Presents
Valu ( Marathi )
Maan Gaye Mughal-E-Azam
Sci-fi Transformers
Must see - on the big screen Watch for sure - preferably in theatre Wait for video release Watch if you have nothing better to do Switch channels if it’s on cable!
Science Fiction Love Story 2050
Slapstick Dhamaal
Heyy Babyy
C Kkompany
Dhol
Jaan-E-Mann
Krazzy 4
Maan Gaye Mughal-E-Azam
Mere Baap Pehle Aap
One Two Three
Partner
Singh is Kinng
Apna Sapna Money Money
Bhagam Bhag
Bombay to Bangkok
Bombay to Goa
buddha mar gaya
Golmaal Returns
Hari Puttar
Hattrick
Kudiyon Ka Hai Zamana
Money Hai To Honey Hai
Rama Rama Kya Hai Dramaaa
Welcome
Social Lage Raho Munnabhai
Tare Zameen Par
1971
A Mighty Heart
A Wednesday
Aaja Nachle
Aamir
CHAKDE! INDIA
Kabul Express
Khuda Ke Liye
No Smoking
Parzania
Ramchand Pakistani
Summer 2007
Tahaan
Traffic Signal
Welcome to Sajjanpur
Baabul
Dhokha
Hope and a little sugar
It’s Breaking News
Mumbai Meri Jaan
Provoked
Return of Hanuman
Valu ( Marathi )
Water
Bhool Bhulaiyaa
Black and White
Black Friday
C Kkompany
EMI
Halla Bol
Laaga Chunari Mein Daag
Sunday
Dhan Dhana Dhan Goal
Gauri The Unborn
Money Hai To Honey Hai
Spoof Salaam-e-Ishq Om Shanti Om
Sport Jannat
Sports Chain Kulii Ki Main Kulii
CHAKDE! INDIA
Ta Ra Rum Pum Aryan
Dhan Dhana Dhan Goal
Hattrick
Suspense Johnny Gaddar
Manorama Six Feet Under
Checkmate ( Marathi )
Dus Kahaniyaan
Race
Via Darjeeling
Aggar
Naqaab
Sunday
Bas Ek Pal
Darling
Speed
Terrorism A Mighty Heart
A Wednesday
Khuda Ke Liye
Parzania
Tahaan
Contract
Dhokha
Mumbai Meri Jaan
Black and White
Black Friday
Hijack
Mission Istanbul
Must see - on the big screen Watch for sure - preferably in theatre Wait for video release Watch if you have nothing better to do Switch channels if it’s on cable!
Thriller 1971
A Wednesday
Aamir
Don
Ek Chalis Ki Last Local
Johnny Gaddar
Manorama Six Feet Under
Michael Clayton
Quantum of Solace
The Bourne Ultimatum
Checkmate ( Marathi )
Ghajini
Kidnap
Maharathi
Mithya
Race
Strangers
The Kingdom
1920
Aggar
Deadline - Sirf 24 Ghante
Eklavya
Hijack
Naqaab
Righteous Kill
Aap Kaa Suroor
Red
Speed
Tragedy Umrao Jaan Woh Lamhe Khoya Khoya Chand
War 1971
Kabul Express
Heroes Jodhaa Akbar